Conquerors of the Roman Empire: The Vandals

  First published in Great Britain in 2016 by

  Pen & Sword Military

  An imprint of

  Pen & Sword Books Ltd

  47 Church Street

  Barnsley

  South Yorkshire

  S70 2AS

  Copyright © Simon MacDowall, 2016

  ISBN: 978 1 47383 770 6

  PDF ISBN: 978 1 47388 023 8

  EPUB ISBN: 978 1 47388 022 1

  PRC ISBN: 978 1 47388 021 4

  The right of Simon MacDowall to be identified as Author of this work has been asserted by him in accordance with the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988.

  A CIP catalogue record for this book is

  available from the British Library

  All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical including photocopying, recording or by any information storage and retrieval system, without permission from the Publisher in writing.

  Typeset in Ehrhardt by

  Replika Press Pvt Ltd, India

  Printed and bound in England

  By CPI Group (UK) Ltd, Croydon, CR0 4YY

  Pen & Sword Books Ltd incorporates the Imprints of Pen & Sword Aviation, Pen & Sword Family History, Pen & Sword Maritime, Pen & Sword Military, Pen & Sword Discovery, Pen & Sword Politics, Pen & Sword Atlas, Pen & Sword Archaeology, Wharncliffe Local History, Wharncliffe True Crime, Wharncliffe Transport, Pen & Sword Select, Pen & Sword Military Classics, Leo Cooper, The Praetorian Press, Claymore Press, Remember When, Seaforth Publishing and Frontline Publishing.

  For a complete list of Pen & Sword titles please contact

  PEN & SWORD BOOKS LIMITED

  47 Church Street, Barnsley, South Yorkshire, S70 2AS, England

  E-mail: enquiries@pen-and-sword.co.uk

  Website: www.pen-and-sword.co.uk

  Contents

  List of Plates

  List of Maps

  Chapter 1 Germania

  Chapter 2 In the Bleak Midwinter

  Chapter 3 A Spanish Interlude

  Chapter 4 Into Africa

  Chapter 5 Mare Nostrum

  Chapter 6 The Next Generation

  Chapter 7 The Empire Strikes Back

  Chapter 8 Moors and Mutineers

  Chronology

  The Vandal and Alan Kings

  The Later Roman Emperors

  Glossary

  Select Bibliography

  List of Plates

  1. A rare depiction of a mounted Germanic warrior. (Landesmuseum für Vorgeschichte, Halle)

  2. Silver spurs from a third century Germanic noble’s grave. (British Museum, author’s photo)

  3. Sarmatian warriors depicted on Trajan’s Column. (Author’s photo)

  4. Roman cavalry helmet. (Rijksmuseum voor Oudheden, Leiden, photo Michiel)

  5. Page from a medieval copy of the Notitia Dignitatum showing the cities under the control of the Dux Mogontiacensis. (Bodleian manuscript)

  6. A reconstructed ship of the Roman Rhine fleet. (The Museum of Ancient Shipping, Mainz)

  7. General Stilicho, his wife Serena and son Eucherius. (Monza Cathedral)

  8. Alan wearing scale armour and carrying a lance. (Hermitage Museum, St Petersburg)

  9. Fishing boat of a type commandeered by the Vandals. (Bardo Museum, author’s photo)

  10. Transports for cavalry horses. (Bardo Museum, author’s photo)

  11. The Dominus Julius’ villa in Africa Proconsularis. (Bardo Museum, author’s photo)

  12. Luxury ceramics known as African sigillata. (Bardo Museum, author’s photo)

  13. North African merchant ship. (Bardo Museum, author’s photo)

  14. Roman soldiers defending a city from marauding tribesmen. (Museum für Byzantinische Kunst, Berlin)

  15. Frontispiece from the Notitia Dignitatum. (Bodleian manuscript)

  16. Silver plate celebrating the appointment of Flavius Ardabur Aspar as Consul of Africa. (National Archaeological Museum, Florence, photo by Sailko)

  17. The ruins of Roman Carthage. (Author’s photo)

  18. A necklace and earrings from the so-called Carthage Treasure. (British Museum, author’s photo)

  19. A fifth-century funerary mosaic depicting a Roman banker from Thabraca (Tabarka). (Bardo Museum, author’s photo)

  20. Fifth-century funeral mosaic of a ship owner. (Bardo Museum, author’s photo)

  21. The gravestone of a priest from the Basilica of Vitalis (Sbeitla) in Byzacena. (Bardo Museum, author’s photo)

  22. Fourth-century mosaic of Ulysses tied to a mast to resist the Sirens. (Bardo Museum, author’s photo)

  23. A fifth-century East Roman infantryman. (Istanbul Archeological Museum, author’s photo)

  24. The military port of Carthage. (Author’s photo)

  25. The Vandals’ fourteen-day sack of Rome, 455. (Tretyakov Gallery, Moscow)

  26. Vandal horseman riding in front of a villa appropriated from its former Roman owner. (British Museum, author’s photo)

  27. A Vandal hunting. (British Museum)

  28. Items from a Vandal woman’s grave in North Africa. (British Museum, author’s photo)

  29. Engraving on a sixth-century Vandal belt buckle. (British Museum, author’s photo)

  30. Moor light cavalry. (Trajan’s column, Rome, author’s photo)

  31. Vandal coin depicting a Vandal. (British Museum)

  32. A reconstruction of a dromon. (Model Ship Master)

  33. Mosaic depicting the Emperor Justinian surrounded by ecclesiastic and secular officials and guardsmen. (Church of San Vitale, Ravenna)

  34. Silver dish depicting a sixth-century East Roman soldier riding down a Lombard. (Photo James Steakley)

  35. Sixth-century Egyptian ivory showing late Roman troops. (Rheinisches Landes Museum Trier)

  36. Hunting scene from the late-fifth/early-sixth century. (Bardo Museum, author’s photo)

  37. Carthaginian water cisterns. (La Malga, Tunisia, author’s photo)

  List of Maps

  1. Vandal Settlements in Germania

  2. The Vandal Migration in the fifth century

  3. The Defence of the Roman Empire AD 400

  4. The Vandals, Alans and Suevi in Gaul AD 407-409

  5. The Vandals in Spain AD 409-429

  6. Roman North Africa AD 429

  7. Europe and North Africa AD 533

  8a. The Battle of Ad Decimum – Opening Moves

  8b. The Battle of Ad Decimum – Initial Contact

  8c. The Battle of Ad Decimum – Roman Victory

  Chapter 1

  Germania

  The Vandals

  The very name conjures up violent images of wanton destruction. It is the label given to those that deliberately destroy or damage property and it is the lasting epithet of the ancient Germanic tribe that carved a kingdom out of Roman Africa in the fifth century AD.

  Of all the conquerors of the Roman Empire the Vandals surely have had the worst press. The Greeks and Romans called anyone living beyond the bounds of their Mediterranean civilization a ‘barbarian’. This pejorative term has also found its way into modern usage implying, as it did in ancient times, someone who is uncouth, uneducated and uncivilized. A ‘vandal’ seems to be one step further beyond the pale.

  Who then were these people whose name has been preserved for nearly 1,700 years as the epitome of barbaric savagery? Do they deserve their reputation or is there more to their story?

  The original Vandals sacked Rome in 455 but they were not the first to do so. Alaric’s Goths captured the eternal city forty years earlier, spending three days looting, pillaging an
d plundering. St Augustine was living in Hippo Regius as the Vandals were besieging that city, which they later sacked. For many early Christians the horrors of barbarian invasion was seen as God’s righteous wrath and punishment for their sins. The Vandals, although Christians themselves by this time, followed the teachings of the Bishop Arius and vigorously persecuted the Romans who believed that the Arian version of Christianity was heresy. All of this added up to an impression that the Vandals were bent on the destruction of all that was good and civilized.

  As far as it is possible to tell, the term ‘vandalism’ first came to be equated with wanton destruction in the eighteenth century. In 1794, Henri Grégoire, the bishop of Blois, described the destruction of artwork in the French Revolution as ‘vandalisme’. The term stuck, even if the original Vandals were perhaps no more or less destructive than any of the other conquerors of ancient Rome. The Vandals are credited with defacing Roman monuments but in truth, much of the destruction of classical architecture was carried out by local inhabitants re-using building materials along with pious Christians taking offence at nudity and pagan symbolism.

  Despite the real horrors of invasion by a foreign people who then become unsympathetic overlords, there is indeed much more to the narrative of the Vandals. Their story is actually quite remarkable. After very little contact with the Greco-Roman world, they emerged from the forests of central Europe in the early fifth century. They crossed the Rhine in midwinter, ravaged Gaul (modern France and Belgium) then passed through the Pyrenees. They briefly ruled over parts of Spain but in 429 they were on the move again. They crossed from Spain into Africa and took the Roman province for themselves.

  It may be that the name of the Vandals comes from the same root as the modern German ‘wandeln’ (in German the letter ‘w’ is pronounced as the English ‘v’). From this we get the English word ‘wanderer’. If so it is an apt name. The Vandals were indeed wanderers, moving from Scandinavia to central Europe, then down to the Danube before crossing the Rhine, passing through France into Spain, and finally ending up in Africa.

  Once established in Africa, these people from the land-locked forests of central Europe ruled the Mediterranean with their fleets, defying both the West and East Roman Empires. From a small insignificant tribe amongst many, they had emerged as one of the most powerful kingdoms of the fifth century. Their moment in the African sun was, however, very short lived. In 533 the East Romans, under the inspired leadership of Belisarius, crushed the Vandals and wiped out all traces of their kingdom except for the memory of their name as destroyers of civilization.

  This book will examine how the Vandals managed to achieve such stunning success and then lose it all in a brief campaign. It will focus on the military aspects: how their armies were formed, their tactics, equipment and how they compared with their opponents. As a consequence the book will concentrate primarily on the great migration that led to the foundation of their African kingdom and its reconquest by Justinian’s East Romans. All of this will be placed in the political, religious and social context of the times.

  Our Sources

  The Vandals left very little archeological record. Therefore in reconstructing their story we have to rely primarily on literary sources. Unfortunately, unlike many of the other conquerors of the Roman Empire such as the Goths, Franks, Lombards and Saxons, the Vandals had no one to write their history from their point of view. The only contemporary records that we have, were written by their Roman enemies.

  The end of the Vandal kingdom is very well documented by Procopius, secretary to the Roman general Belisarius who led the campaign which defeated the Vandals. Procopius was actually present at many of the incidents he recounted and took an active part in the campaign. As a result we have detailed accounts of the battles and skirmishes that took place between the Roman invasion of Africa in 533 and the end of the last free Vandals in 546. Although obviously biased, Procopius’s history is reasonably balanced. His descriptions of the battles, the numbers of troops involved and the various political machinations are both realistic and reliable.

  The same cannot be said about any of the sources prior to this. Before their crossing of the Rhine in the early-fifth century, the Vandals were a relatively minor Germanic people and are only mentioned in passing by various Roman authors. Once they moved into Roman territory their story is recounted in horror by several chroniclers, all of whom were churchmen who took great exception to the Vandals’ heretical beliefs.

  After crossing the Rhine on the last day of 406, the Vandals spent three years ravaging France. Yet the sum total of what contemporary chroniclers have to say about this amounts to no more than a few hundred words. Other than listing the cities that fell to the Vandals and some hints of other actions, Saint Jerome, Prosper of Aquitaine and others do not tell us how they did it, what sort of defence the Romans conducted nor any detail of the many skirmishes, sieges and battles that must have taken place between 406 and 409.

  Once the Vandals crossed into Spain, the Spanish Bishop Hydatius gives us a little more detail. Hydatius lived through the Vandal occupation of Spain and spent several months as a prisoner of the Suevi who had accompanied the Vandals from Germany into Spain. Even though Hydatius tells us something about the events that took place in his country between 409 and 429, he is terribly short on detail. For example he says: ‘the barbarians ran wild through the Spanish provinces’, but does not say anything about how they managed to take most of the peninsular for themselves.

  The story of the Vandals’ early years in Africa suffers from the same problem. Several bishops, Victor of Vita being the most notable, wrote about the suffering of Roman orthodox Christians at the hands of the Vandals. We hear how the Vandals ‘set to work on (Africa) with their wicked forces, laying it waste by devastation and bringing everything to ruin with fire and murders.’ Once again we do not learn how they did it, nor how they managed to defeat the Roman armies sent against them.

  Therefore, in telling the Vandals’ fascinating story, I have had to frequently fall back on conjecture. I have tried to piece together the frustratingly sparse contemporary evidence, match it with other original sources that tell us something about the politics and military actions of the age and come up with conclusions that seem right, even if we are unlikely to ever know for certain. In this regard there are a couple of other invaluable contemporary sources. The first of these is the history of Ammianus Marcellinus – a fourth century Roman officer turned historian. Although his history ends a couple of decades before the Vandals crossed the Rhine, he does give first hand accounts of late Roman and barbarian warfare as well as observations on many of the peoples who played into the Vandal story. The second is the Notitia Dignitatum, a list of offices and army units from the end of fourth and early-fifth centuries. This tells us the official orders of battle of the Roman Army at the time of the Vandal invasion. While it needs to be treated with a fair degree of caution it is invaluable in building a picture of the Roman Army at the time of the Vandals. The histories and letters of Zosimus, Priscus, Saint Augustine, Olympiodorus, Jordanes, Sidonius Apollinaris and other chroniclers help to fill in some of the blanks.

  I have quite deliberately relied on contemporary accounts rather than more recent histories or interpretations. In fact there are very few modern accounts of the Vandal story. The definitive modern study of the Vandals was written by Christian Courtois in 1955 and since then there have only been a couple of new books about them. There have, of course, been many new investigations of the fall of the West Roman Empire and late Roman warfare. Many of these have been very helpful in placing the story of the Vandals in a wider political, military and economic context. I have listed the most useful ones in the bibliography.

  The Origins of the Vandals

  The Vandals were an east Germanic people who crossed the Rhine in the early fifth century and ended up in Africa. This much is certain. Tracing back their origins and forming any idea of what their ancestors were like is much less so.

/>   Tacitus, in his first century work Germania, recounts oral German tradition in which three groups of tribes – the Ingaevones; the Hermiones and the Istaevones were descended from the son of the earth-born god Tuisto. He then goes on to say:

  ‘Some authorities, with the freedom of conjecture permitted by remote antiquity, assert that Tuisto had more numerous descendants and mention more tribal groups such as Marsi, Gambrivii, Suevi and Vandillii – names which they affirm to be both genuine and ancient.’

  It would seem that Tacitus is sceptical of this claim, even though he is quite tactful in the way he expresses his doubt. Unfortunately, after this brief introduction, Tactius does not mention the Vandals again. When he goes through his descriptions of each of the Germanic tribes he says nothing about the Vandals or Vandillii.

  Pliny the Elder also mentions the Vandilii in his Natural History, written in AD 77. He lists them as one of the five most important German tribes alongside the Burgundians, Goths, Varini and Charini. Interestingly, Pliny adds that the Burgundians were a part of the Vandal people. Close cooperation between the later Siling Vandals and Burgundians may lend some credence to this claim.

  Norse and Germanic legends recount stories of migrations from Scandinavia into central Europe in which the Germanic peoples displaced or absorbed the earlier Celtic inhabitants. This is certainly the Gothic tradition and it is backed up with some archeological and etymological evidence. The same may be true of the Vandals. However, Tacitus’ story and Jordanes, history of the Goths may indicate that the Vandals were already living in central Europe when the Goths and others moved south.

  Jordanes wrote in the sixth century for a Gothic audience. As such he glorifies the deeds of that people at the expense of others. In the fifth century the Goths and Vandals were bitter enemies. Jordanes traces this enmity back in the mists of time when the Goths first moved from Scandinavia to Germany, ‘subdued their neighbours, the Vandals, and thus added to their victories.’ By the third century the Goths were settled north of the Black Sea ‘holding undisputed sway over great stretches of country, many arms of the sea and many river courses. By their strong right arm the Vandals were often laid low.’